Most people who overpay for a used car don’t get fooled on the price. They get caught on the rate, the fees, the add-ons, or a car with problems nobody mentioned. Here’s the checklist we’d give our own family.

Happy customers at Main Street Motors in Portage, IN
Key takeaways
  • Get your out-the-door price in writing.
  • Indiana dealers must disclose salvage or rebuilt history in writing, and the Buyers Guide tells you the warranty status.
  • Settle the price of the car before you talk trade-in.

1. Know your numbers before you walk in

Walk in knowing what the bank can offer you, and you stay in control of the deal. Get your rate, payment, and down payment first, either through a preapproval at your bank or a soft-credit pre-qualification. Read why good credit doesn’t always mean a good rate.

2. Get the out-the-door price in writing

Ask for the full out-the-door price before you visit. See our guide to hidden dealer fees.

3. Check the history and the title

The Indiana Attorney General recommends researching the VIN with a history service and inspecting the title for brands like “salvage,” “rebuild,” or “reconstructed.” Dealers must tell you in writing about a previous salvage or rebuilt condition before you buy. (Indiana AG: Purchasing a Car) More in rebuilt vs. salvage titles.

4. Read the Buyers Guide

Every used car a dealer offers for sale must have a Buyers Guide. It tells you whether the car comes with a warranty or is sold as-is, and it overrides the sales contract if they conflict.

5. Get an independent inspection

A history report won’t show mechanical problems. An independent mechanic’s inspection is a smart step, even on certified cars. See how to test drive and inspect a used car.

6. Say no to add-ons you don’t want

Service contracts, GAP, and protection packages are optional. Ask what each costs and decide separately. Read whether an extended warranty is worth it.

7. Negotiate the price before the trade-in

The Indiana AG suggests settling the price of the car you’re buying before discussing your trade-in, so one doesn’t get hidden inside the other.

Ready for the next step?
See your financing options, shop our inventory, or get an offer on your trade.

Video transcript

Transcript lightly edited for readability.

Hey, it’s Blake. If you walk into the dealership without knowing what type of offer the bank can give you, you’ve already lost control of your deal. Even people with great credit can get hit with high interest rate markups, high fees, and high-pressure tactics, all because they didn’t check first. A few months ago, me and my brothers were talking here at the dealership. It’s a family business. We wanted to create a system that lets people see their interest rate, monthly payment, and down payment on any vehicle they’re interested in before coming to the dealership. We noticed one of the biggest problems in the industry lately is low prices online, and then when customers come in, they get hit with fees that add thousands onto the loan. So we built a system that lets you see everything before you come in. You put in some basic information. You don’t need your Social Security number, so it doesn’t put a hit on your credit. The software matches you with lenders based on things like your job, income, and credit, including national lenders and local credit unions, and shows you your interest rate, payment, and down payment, even with a trade-in you still owe on. That way you come in prepared instead of guessing. And you’re not committing to anything. You’re just seeing the numbers before you come in.

FAQs

How do I avoid getting ripped off buying a used car?

Know your financing numbers first, get the out-the-door price in writing, check the history and title, read the Buyers Guide, and get an independent inspection.

Do Indiana dealers have to disclose a salvage or rebuilt title?

Yes. According to the Indiana Attorney General, dealers must tell you in writing about a previous salvage or rebuilt condition before you buy.

Is there a cooling-off period after buying a car in Indiana?

Don’t count on one. Get any return or refund promise in writing on your contract before you sign.