5020 US-6, Portage, IN
(219) 476-0005
Closed. Opens Tuesday at 9:00 AM
Closed. Opens Tuesday at 9:00 AM

Customer reviews at Main Street Motors in Portage, IN

We’re in the business of making friends and making a difference.

We’re not just here to sell cars. Sure, you’ll find an outstanding selection of used vehicles on our dealership lot, but that’s far from our only mission at Main Street Motors. To us, making friends means creating a welcoming environment and fostering a relationship where you don’t just become a customer, you become a friend.


Review from mARY Ponder
mARY Ponder
9/9/2025
This is an excellent place to buy a vehicle- I have purchased 4 cars from here
Review from Nick Elliott (OpticZen Gaming)
Nick Elliott (OpticZen Gaming)
8/13/2025
Customer service has been an incredible experience. Lon has been a delight to work with, and their honesty and commitment to helping their customers has been a huge relief compared to larger dealerships. I couldn't recommend them enough.
Review from Matthew Brown
Matthew Brown
7/18/2025
My family has purchased several vehicles from here and we have been pleased with every one of them! Josh gets things done where other places wouldn't even try for us. Sales people were friendly and didnt pressure us. Once we picked out what we wanted each time, it went smooth and they walked us through every step along the way.
Review from Micah Harris
Micah Harris
7/17/2025
I wanted to write an appreciation review for Ben. He was not pushy, and was forthright about the car we were looking at. After purchasing the car, there was a repair that was needed a week later. Jay Wolfe honored their 30-day warranty and did the work. I’m very happy and am telling others, “Jay Wolfe is a great spot to shop for vehicles .” Thank you Ben!
Review from Lori Ebner
Lori Ebner
7/10/2025
This was the absolute best car buying experience we’ve encountered. Our extremely knowledgeable sales associate, Lon, exuded honesty, transparency, and kindness. The finance manager, Josh, exceeded our expectations as well. Hopefully, the truck we purchased behaves itself! It definitely seems as though they have it in tip top shape :)
Review from Jessica S
Jessica S
7/1/2025
I had a great experience with my Audi. Josh, Steve and Ben were exceptional. You won’t be disappointed doing business at Jay Wolfe
Review from Megan Coovert
Megan Coovert
6/17/2025
Lon at Jay Wolfe was amazing!! 10/10 customer service. I was in a bind, and she helped me tremendously! I would recommend her to anyone!
Review from Justin Shonamon
Justin Shonamon
6/3/2025
Ben was super helpful and made the purchase of our van a very easy process.
Review from Dana Forrester
Dana Forrester
5/24/2025
We live 4.5 hrs away and asked for additional photos and information on a vehicle we were interested in. Steve obliged and while we did not decide on that one, his honesty and transparency was much appreciated and kept us from a long drive for something we ultimately did not purchase. We will definitely be keeping an eye on their inventory, highly recommend. Shockingly honest and transparent; thank you!
Review from Sarah Miller
Sarah Miller
5/21/2025
We had such a great experience with Lon and so far so good with our car! Lon went above and beyond throughout the whole process and we couldn’t be happier!! Highly recommend everyone in the shop!
Review from Madison Zylstra
Madison Zylstra
2/12/2025
Tommy and Rena were so professional, kind, and caring - despite our long evening and staying WAY late. Tommy is extremely responsive and laid back as a car salesman - not pushy - and let us explore SEVERAL options. Ran numbers so many times and just delivered 110% of their time and energy! Thank you so much y’all!
Review from Dan Walker
Dan Walker
1/18/2025
Bertt Woodward is a service writer there in their body shop. He did an outstanding job with coordinating their woks and keeping me informed of their progress and future plans. Good job Brett. Keep up the good work !!
Review from Tobi San Agustin
Tobi San Agustin
12/17/2024
Good cars at a decent price. Impressed with the salesman.
Review from Joshua Joestar
Joshua Joestar
11/21/2024
Very good staff, they helped me on multiple occasions free of charge with my vehicle I purchased from them. They are knowledgeable and reliable. Special thanks to Lon Smilor too.
Review from LaMoine Marcum
LaMoine Marcum
11/18/2024
Very helpful staff.