If your car loan APR is high even with good credit, there are two common reasons: the dealership may not work with prime lenders, or the rate may be marked up. In this video, Blake from Main Street Motors explains both, and what you can do about each.

Happy customers at Main Street Motors in Portage, IN
Key takeaways
  • Your rate depends on which lenders a dealer works with and whether the rate is marked up.
  • The CFPB says auto loan rates are negotiable.
  • Get pre-qualified or preapproved so you have a rate to compare.
  • Multiple auto loan inquiries within about 14 to 45 days generally count as one, per the CFPB.

Reason 1: The dealership doesn’t have access to prime lenders

Not every dealership is set up with the banks and credit unions that offer the best rates. Some lenders require a dealer to have years in business or a certain volume before they’ll work with them. If a dealer can only send your application to a handful of lenders, you may not see the best rate you qualify for.

Reason 2: The rate is being marked up

When you finance through a dealer, the lender quotes the dealer a rate called the buy rate. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that dealers may charge you more than the buy rate as compensation, and that the rate is negotiable. Federal regulators have found lender policies that allowed markups of roughly two percentage points or more.

A common pattern: a car is priced low online to get you in the door, then the deal is sold on the monthly payment, and the rate never really gets discussed.

How to protect yourself

  1. Ask for the rate, not just the payment. Get the APR, term, and amount financed in writing.
  2. Get a preapproval from your bank or credit union so you have something to compare.
  3. Ask directly: “Is this the best rate I qualify for?”
  4. Shop lenders in a short window. The CFPB says auto loan inquiries generally count as one if made within 14 to 45 days.

Want the bigger picture? Read how car loan interest rates are set.

See your real rate before you visit

Our online pre-qualification starts with a soft credit check, so you can see real options from our lenders before you ever set foot on the lot.

Ready for the next step?
See your financing options, shop our inventory, or get an offer on your trade.

Video transcript

Transcript lightly edited for readability.

So, you have good credit, but the dealership’s not giving you a good interest rate. Why is that? This is mainly one of two things. First off, this tends to happen more at smaller dealerships. A lot of times they’re not set up with the right banking institutions. Sometimes they don’t get approved for working with banks who give really good interest rates, or prime lending. Sometimes you need years in business or the right relationships to get that. A lot of bigger dealerships will have good prime lenders, good local credit unions, certain banks and stuff like that. And the second thing is very simply, they’re marking up your interest rate. A ton of dealerships do this. The bank actually allows the dealership to mark up your interest rate, often two to two and a half percent, and the dealership gets to keep the majority of that difference. The banks do this to incentivize the dealership to do business with them, because not only are they making profit off the car, they’re making profit off your interest rate. So a lot of times, not every time, the price might be cheaper than other dealerships. It’s kind of a bait and switch. They’ll price the vehicle cheaper, get you in, and then they’ll sell you on a payment. Sometimes they won’t even go over your interest rate unless you ask for it. You can stop this by getting a pre-approval at your local credit union. Just make sure you’re going to a dealership that has good financing, get your own financing, or make sure they’re not marking up your rate. A lot of people say, “I got my own pre-approval from my bank.” That’s really good. There’s a lot of leverage dealerships have, though. We do a lot of deals with the banks every month. You buy a car maybe once every couple of years. So the bank has more incentive to give us the better rate because we send them so much business. Not 100% of the time, but a lot of the time, a dealership with good lenders should be able to get you a better interest rate than your own local credit union.

FAQs

Why is my car loan rate high when my credit is good?

Usually because the dealer either doesn’t work with prime lenders or is marking up the lender’s buy rate. Ask for the APR in writing and compare it with a preapproval.

Can a dealer mark up my interest rate?

Yes. The CFPB explains dealers may charge more than the lender’s buy rate, and that the rate is negotiable.

Should I get preapproved before going to a dealership?

It’s a smart move. A preapproval gives you a benchmark, and a dealer with strong lender relationships may be able to beat it.