By the Main Street Motors team · Updated November 2026

If you drive I-94 every day, toward Chicago, Gary or Michigan City, fuel adds up fast. A car with strong EPA ratings can make a real difference over a year of commuting.

Here are the best commuter picks on our lot by EPA combined mpg, plus what the EPA and Department of Energy say about winter driving.

Used 2025 Toyota Camry LE hybrid at Main Street Motors
What you'll learn
  • Which cars on our lot have the best EPA mpg
  • How hybrids compare with gas sedans and crossovers
  • Why winter lowers your mpg and what helps
  • How to keep your commuter running efficiently

Commuter picks by EPA rating

VehicleTypeEPA combined mpg
2025 Toyota Camry LEHybrid sedan51
2025 Toyota Corolla LEGas sedan34 to 35, by version
2023 Nissan Rogue SV AWDCrossover31
2025 Hyundai Kona SEL FWD, 2.0LSmall crossover31
2024 Toyota Camry SE AWDGas sedan29
2023 Kia K5 GT-Line AWDGas sedan28
2025 Ford Escape AWD, 1.5LCrossover28
EPA ratings for each version. Snapshot from November 2026.

Why the Camry hybrid stands out

Toyota made every 2025 Camry a hybrid, and the EPA rates the front-wheel-drive LE at 51 mpg combined. Hybrids use regenerative braking to recapture energy when you slow down and an electric motor to help the engine, according to the EPA and DOE. Learn more in our hybrid vs plug-in hybrid guide.

What winter does to your mpg

The EPA and DOE report that a gas car's fuel economy is about 15% lower in city driving at 20°F than at 77°F, and can drop as much as 24% on short trips. Hybrids can drop about 30% to 34%. Their tips: park in a garage when you can, combine trips, limit idling to about 30 seconds and keep tires properly inflated.

Shop used sedans for commuting

Live from our inventory.
White 2019 Ford Taurus Sedan 4D Police Interceptor AWD 3.7L V6 for sale in Portage, INPhotos of 2019 Ford Taurus Sedan 4D Police Interceptor AWD 3.7L V6 for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsAnother view of 2019 Ford Taurus Sedan 4D Police Interceptor AWD 3.7L V6 for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsMore photos of 2019 Ford Taurus Sedan 4D Police Interceptor AWD 3.7L V6 at Main Street Motors, INMore photos of 2019 Ford Taurus Sedan 4D Police Interceptor AWD 3.7L V6 at Main Street Motors, IN
Sedan 4D Police Interceptor AWD 3.7L V6
Est. Payment
$220/mo
Gray 2018 MAZDA MAZDA6 Signature Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, INPhotos of 2018 MAZDA MAZDA6 Signature Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsAnother view of 2018 MAZDA MAZDA6 Signature Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsMore photos of 2018 MAZDA MAZDA6 Signature Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, INMore photos of 2018 MAZDA MAZDA6 Signature Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, IN
was $21,500
$20,965
Est. Payment
$323/mo
Gray 2023 Dodge Charger SXT Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, INPhotos of 2023 Dodge Charger SXT Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsAnother view of 2023 Dodge Charger SXT Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsMore photos of 2023 Dodge Charger SXT Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, INMore photos of 2023 Dodge Charger SXT Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, IN
was $25,999
$22,765
Est. Payment
$321/mo
Silver 2025 Toyota Camry LE Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, INPhotos of 2025 Toyota Camry LE Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsAnother view of 2025 Toyota Camry LE Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsMore photos of 2025 Toyota Camry LE Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, INMore photos of 2025 Toyota Camry LE Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, IN
was $25,500
$24,965
Est. Payment
$352/mo
Gray 2023 Kia K5 GT-Line Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, INPhotos of 2023 Kia K5 GT-Line Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsAnother view of 2023 Kia K5 GT-Line Sedan 4D for sale in Portage, IN at Main Street MotorsMore photos of 2023 Kia K5 GT-Line Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, INMore photos of 2023 Kia K5 GT-Line Sedan 4D at Main Street Motors, IN
GT-Line Sedan 4D
Est. Payment
$352/mo

What to check before you buy

  • Check tire pressure against the door jamb sticker. The EPA and DOE say underinflated tires can lower gas mileage by about 0.2% for every 1 psi drop.
  • Run the VIN for recalls at nhtsa.gov/recalls. It takes about a minute.
  • Read the Buyers Guide on the window. Federal rules require one on every used vehicle a dealer offers for sale, and it shows whether the vehicle comes with a warranty or is sold as is.
  • Ask about service contracts. We offer plans from Integrity and Alpha. Coverage levels, terms and labor rates differ from plan to plan, so ask which ones fit the vehicle you like.
  • Take a real test drive with some highway miles on I-94 or the toll road, and try the brakes, steering and climate controls.

Which one fits your commute?

A hybrid or compact sedan
  • You drive 40+ highway miles a day
  • You want the lowest fuel cost
  • You park in the city
A crossover
  • You want AWD for winter
  • You carry gear or kids
  • You like a higher seating position

Related reading: best gas mileage used cars and winter car checklist.

Cut your commute costs
Shop fuel-efficient cars, get pre-qualified and see what your trade is worth.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best mpg car on your lot?

Right now the 2025 Toyota Camry LE hybrid, rated by the EPA at 51 mpg combined. Inventory changes daily.

Do hybrids work well in Indiana winters?

Yes, though all cars lose some mpg in the cold. The EPA and DOE report hybrids lose about 30% to 34% in cold weather, so the Camry still beats most gas cars.

Is AWD worth it for commuting?

It helps in snow, but it usually costs a little mpg. The EPA rates the 2023 Rogue at 33 mpg combined with FWD and 31 with AWD.

Does idling to warm up help?

The EPA and DOE suggest limiting idling to about 30 seconds and then driving gently. Idling gets 0 mpg.
Get your trade-in value
What's your car worth?
Get My Instant Trade Offer
Check out our featured vehicles